There has been a run on blame-sharing recently. Keep an eye out for it. Blame-sharing is the viral mutation of blame-shifting, and it is deadly. Honest, it is deadly.
Blame-shifting is when we accuse someone else for what we have done wrong. It was popular in the 1970’s, and I personally stuck with it long enough to bring it into my early-1980’s marriage, which is still my marriage. For the first five years my wife, I am sure, must have been scratching her head at how I had become more perfect and she had become more sinful. Somehow, she was responsible for all our marital difficulties. By the late 1980’s I finally caught up with cultural trends and saw how sinful and out-of-date (see my last blog on “Boring”) I had become. So, I don’t blame-shift anymore because of a combination of sanctification mixed with my fear of becoming a cliché. Now, only the most Neanderthal among us indulges in such sin.
We have become more sophisticated.
“I know I am a sinner. Now she has to accept responsibility for her own sin.” “I don’t mind owning what is mine, but she is not confessing her part in this.”
There are different versions of blame-sharing. In its most common form, men want their spouses to acknowledge at least half of all the sins in the house. It is basic math: sin, divided by two sinners = .5 for him and .5 for her. Sounds symmetrical and, maybe, okay, at least on the surface. But there is usually much more to blame-sharing. For example, when the man’s sin is especially prominent, the wife still must accept at least half the blame, and she should acknowledge her sin first (because her sins are the worse half). Husbands who confess first usually do it out of self-righteousness – just watch to see if they get angry when their spouse either doesn’t acknowledge enough sin or doesn’t praise the husband enough for his massive humility. (Do I sound like I am getting ticked off?) If the wife’s sin is especially prominent she must accept all the blame.
Yes, blame-sharing is a tragedy.
I have observed blame-sharing often over the last year – once you begin to see it, you see it everywhere. No doubt, women can have their own version of it, so if you are a woman and have snuck a peek at this blog I don’t want to stop you from considering yourself and your own gender on these things, but I am seeing it a lot in men. The scary part is that I have yet to see any of these men change. Every time I have seen blame-sharing, at least up to this week, I have yet to see a man even acknowledge the wrongness of it let alone repent of it. So, in order to learn how to help other men, I have spoken to some other counselor-types about this, and I am finding something even more frightening: though I have spoken to counselors who initially say that they have seen men turn away from blame-sharing, when I asked them to get more specific they couldn’t cite anyone who had actually changed. I hope they simply forgot some of the success stories. Given more time to consider my question, I like to think they could have remembered some. But the conversations were enough to leave me a little more scared of sin. The Spirit can change us, of that we are sure. But spiritual blindness can still afflict anyone at anytime.
We can provoke one-another to sin, and such provocation itself is sinful. In most marital conflicts both people sin, but men must commit to at least two basic spiritual principles. First, my sin is my sin, no one else can make me sin. Second, according to Matthew 7:3-5 (…the speck and the plank), I must despise certain forms of symmetry. When it comes to sin, I want to see my sin as worse than the other person’s. Any other approach will, guaranteed, trash the marital relationship.
Yes, I will ask to see if my wife ever sees this in me, and if she sees it I will persuade her to accept only 49.6% of the blame, being the good husband that I am, because after all she has . . . .
If this article has been helpful to you, won't you share it with your friends? Use the buttons below to email the article or post it to various social media outlets.
Comments
Thank you for identifying this for me. I have realized this is something I struggle with in my heart. It hasn't come out in conflicts with my wife verbally as much as it has internally. Especially since I feel the need to "offer counseling" to her in the midst of her struggle. After all, I was humble enough to admit my sin, so my spouse should follow suit. And who better than me to point out her sin after I have "come clean." This is nothing short of manipulation and completely misses the point of confession and humility. We don't confess our sin in order to get our wives to confess theirs. We confess because we have sinned and it needs to be confessed regardless of the sin in the hearts of our spouses. Far too often, I am too righteous in my own eyes. Your identifying this phenomenon of blame-sharing will help me grow in humility as I face conflicts with my wife.
The previous person to comment on this said it well. I had noticed I was doing something like this. My wife has commented that she is not always to blame in things. I see that I need to own what is really mine, but it is difficult. Hopefully this clear identifying will help me. I wanted to leave one caution, though, and perhaps I do so with the risk of sounding like I am trying to give myself/other men an out, but I think it is part of being biblically balanced. The Ephesians 5 passage on husbands requires them to disciple their wives. It is good to get this blame-sharing thing dealt with, but it would be very bad, also, for men to go back to the 90's 'sensitive man' attitude in which men did not strongly lead in order to be soft and pleasing to women. The speck and log is very important -- that always gets me in the gut -- but it would be very helpful to see some comments that balance the need to repent of blame-sharing with the continuing need to disciple our wives.
I highly praise and bless you Mr Welch for stating what you did. My husband of 15yrs has done nothing but blame me for his verbal and sometimes physical abuse. My marriage is nothing more than a blame game. He loves the Lord so I have a hard time figuring out why he acts the way he does and often think of him as a hypocrite. There is a certain degree of faith I've lost for God because of it. I've prayed so long for a change I've lost hope. I wish you were closer to Denver! Anyways, I am seriously contemplating divorce today after being told by him yesterday that "He doesn't love me enough to change his behavior". I hope and pray you read this I need so much to hear some guidence, what ever that may be, from someone who knows. Thank You!!!